Jewish History in Vesalius’s Fabrica

Historiated Initials from the De humani corporis fabrica by AndrThis is another post to mark the 500th birthday of Andreas Vesalius, author of the great anatomy text entitled De Humani Corporis Fabrica (On the Fabric of the Human Body) – the lavishly illustrated masterpiece that combined art and medicine. The Fabrica will be 472 years old this year, and in this post I will reveal a previously untold secret from inside the book – a story from Jewish history that to my knowledge has never been noted by scholars of Vesalius, but was hiding in plain sight for almost five centuries.

I am a lifelong fan of Vesalius, and after graduating medical school I traveled to Padua, a town in northern Italy just outside of Venice, to walk in his footsteps and see the university where he wrote his famous work. Some years later while browsing a friend’s bookshelf I came across a work by Rabbi Immanuel Jakobovitz entitled Jewish Medical Ethics. Inside I found a passage that left me shaken. Jakobovitz discussed the Jewish community near the medical school at Padua and pointed out that because of the Jewish law that required speedy interment of the dead, their bodies were favored by anatomists. I was shocked as I realized that the great master Vesalius and his students had most likely dissected stolen Jewish bodies, and the illustrations in the Fabrica might have been drawn from these dissections. The often repeated legend states that early anatomists used executed criminals, but it made sense that freshly buried Jewish bodies would make equally choice subjects.

I searched through the available translations of the Fabrica and carefully read Vesalius’s biography, but nowhere is it explicitly stated that he used bodies purloined from Jewish cemeteries. However, historians didn’t look in the right place, for within the Fabrica’s art this fact is revealed.

Like many books printed in the Renaissance, the Fabrica features historiated initials – large embellished letters that begin certain paragraphs. They are called “historiated” because they tell a story. Over the years I had seen a few of the Fabrica’s initials but never had the opportunity to study them closely. I always had a feeling that these letters could yield clues to the question of Jewish grave robbing.

I recently had the opportunity to examine original copies of the Fabrica in the Rare Book Room of the New York Academy of Medicine. I was accompanied by my colleague, the scholar and historian Michael Nevins, with whom I am collaborating on a different topic related to the famous text. To study the historiated initials, I photographed each of them and examined the images in my home.

There are three themes that run through the intials: medical care, preparation of human anatomical specimens, and dissection of animals. Most of the scenes are acted out by putti – chubby naked boys who play the roles of doctors, students, soldiers, and priests. The singular of this Italian word is putto. Historians theorize that at least one set of initials was probably drawn under the supervision of Vesalius by Jan Stephan van Calcar, a student of Titian and the same artist who drew the more famous anatomical dissections.

One initial, the large historiated “I” reproduced above, caught my attention. This initial is larger than most of the others because it introduces one of the seven books rather than a paragraph. It depicts a night scene, and a group of putti are robbing a grave to obtain a body for the anatomy table. One putto holds a candle while two stand guard and others simply watch. One guard has a shield and the second wears a helmet and holds a spear, and their presence infers that the activity is sanctioned by the authorities. The helmeted figure appears distracted as he looks up to see an intruder – a flying putto descending from the sky. In the hand of the flying figure is a pennant, and on the pennant is the letter “O.” Scholars have never explained the meaning of this scene.

Jewish_BadgeI looked at this figure for some time and suddenly realized that the “O” could be the key that reveals the putti are indeed robbing a Jewish cemetery. I did a quick internet search and confirmed my theory. During the late Middle Ages and the Renaissance the “O” was a well recognized symbol of the Jew, mandated by the authorities to wear on their clothing to set them apart in society.

Dr. Flora Cassen is a historian who teaches at University of North Carolina at Chapel hill, and completed her dissertation on discriminatory marks the Jews were compelled to wear in 15th and 16th Century Italy and other countries in Europe. She points out that a Jewish badge in the form of a thin circle of yellow cloth was imposed by the Senate of Venice in 1374, and became the mark of the Jew in northern Italy until the sixteenth century when the authorities changed the “O” to a yellow hat. These laws were a form of sartorial discrimination to construct boundaries between Jews and Christians and implement a social order in which religious groups were separated. Four hundred years later the yellow badge was reintroduced by the Nazi regime, but the shape was changed to the Star of David that came into common use as a Jewish symbol in the 19th Century.

The secret of the historiated “I” in Andreas Vesalius’s De Humani Corporis Fabrica is now revealed. The group of putti are protected by guards in a Jewish cemetery, stealing a recently buried corpse for dissection. A putto carrying the symbol of the Jew flies into the scene in protest, directly confronting the authorities who sanction the sacrilegious act. The Jewish body was certainly used for anatomical study, and might have become immortalized on the illustrated pages of the Fabrica.

I am publishing this story on the eve of the Jewish New Year as it shares a connection with the cycle of life, death, and renewal that is one of the themes of the holiday. There is a tradition in this season to visit the graves of relatives and leave a stone, perhaps with the intent of warding off robbers. Who can comprehend the compounded grief of having a loved one pass on, then end up on the anatomist’s table during the time of mourning? Such was the travail of the Jewish community of Padua, and the story is now evident in the historiated “I” of the Fabrica — in the year that marks the 500th birthday of Andreas Vesalius, and according to Jewish tradition, the 5775th birthday of the world.

 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

All blog posts are copyright © Jeffrey M. Levine 2014 with all rights reserved.  The illustrations in this post are public domain. Please contact me if you would like to reproduce a post.

The historiated “I” above was photographed directly from the 1543 edition of the Fabrica owned by the New York Academy of Medicine. I am indebted to Arlene Shaner, Acting Curator and Reference Librarian for Historical Collections at the Academy for her assistance in viewing these books.  

References for this post:

Immanuel Jakobovits. Jewish Medical Ethics. Philosophical Library, NY 1959.

Flora Cassen. From iconic O to yellow hat: Anti-Jewish distinctive signs in Renaissance Italy. In: Leonard Greenspoon, ed. Studies in Jewish Civilization Volume 24, pp 29-48, 2013.

The illustration was downloaded from Encyclopedia Judaica and features a 16th century Jewish man in Worms, Germany.

For more information on the New York Academy of Medicine’s Vesalius500 celebration click here.

Visit the website of my colleague and mentor in medical history, Dr. Michael Nevins here.

Related posts:

Arion Triumphant
Wounds of a Boxer:  Medical Secrets from Ancient Rome
Painting, Poetry, & Medicine: Charles Demuth and William Carlos Williams

.

Comments(7)

  • June 7, 2016, 12:52 pm  Reply

    Jeffrey Levine’s series of articles on Vesalius’ Fabrica and his historiated letters is fascinating and deserving of further study and development. Most fascinating is the information about the historiated O, and the historical implications regarding treatment of Jews in the Middle Ages, the Renaissance and beyond. Would love to see more !

  • September 22, 2014, 10:11 am  Reply

    Read the irony below discussing the Greek Island of “Zante” where Vesalius died under mysterious conditions. It was this island in WWII where all the Jews were saved by the clergy at risk their own death. Quite amazing that 500 years ago his “team” seemed to be stealing from Jewish graves and the very island he died in and yet this island in Greece was a “safe haven” during another period of brutal anti-semitism!

    During the Nazi occupation of Greece, Mayor Karrer and Bishop Chrysostomos refused Nazi orders to turn in a list of the members of the town’s Jewish community for deportation to the death camps. Instead they hid the town’s 275 Jews in rural villages. Every Jew of Zakynthos survived the war. Statues of the Bishop and the Mayor commemorate their heroism on the site of the town’s historic synagogue, destroyed in the earthquake of 1953. In 1978, Yad Vashem, the Holocaust Martyrs’ and Heroes’ Remembrance Authority in Israel, honored Bishop Chrysostomos and Mayor Loukas Karrer with the title of “Righteous among the Nations”, an honor given to non-Jews who, at personal risk, saved Jews during the Holocaust. After the war, all of the Jews of Zakynthos moved either to Israel or to Athens.

    LEORA GOLDBERG. “The miraculous story of the Jews of Zakynthos”. ZAKYNTHOS, Greece: THE JERUSALEM POST. http://www.jpost.com/Jewish-World/The-miraculous-story-of-the-Jews-of-Zakynthos

  • Joel Ross MD
    September 22, 2014, 9:43 am  Reply

    Once again Jeffrey, you have amazed and dazzled me as well as educated me regarding medical history. I recall the use of “O” which in Yiddish is written as
    “kikel” and when the Jews started coming to Ellis Island, if I am not mistaken the use of the term “Kike” came along and they to had a “0” I believe painted on their garments. Much like they put WHOP painted on some of the Italian immigrants who “were without papers”.

    The below Wiki reference seems to leave this bit of history out of its explanation of why a circle was placed on a Jewish immigrant on Ellis Island.

    I welcome further discussion.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kike

    Joel Ross MD

  • September 22, 2014, 7:56 am  Reply

    I enjoyed ready you’re article about the Vesalius text and the use of Jewish corpses for anatomical dissection. The healing of illness and all that is needed to accomplish that sacred act is a mitzvah, even in the 16th century, although it may not have been thought so at that time.

  • September 22, 2014, 7:52 am  Reply

    Here is a quote from the Jewish Encylcopedia that may answer Bob’s question: “….the university often defended the Jews and endeavored to protect them from violent and illegal measures, while the students were among their best customers. This did not prevent many cases of friction. The students of medicine claimed the corpses of the Jews for anatomical purposes, and often they took them forcibly from the burial-place in spite of the fact that Jews possessed the privilege that the bodies of their dead were not to be touched. For this privilege they paid large sums. Being severely punished, were at last obliged to submit.” (from PADUA in Jewish Encyclopedia. see http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=8&letter=P)

    Of course, Jewish students had to pay double tuition plus extra taxes such as for sweetmeats or to purchase 170 pounds of confetti for the celebration of the first snow, etc. and after graduation they had to invite the entire student body of about 1,000 to dinner. So, yes, the Jewish students were good “customers.”
    As mentioned in an earlier e-mail, they also paid extra (I think 200 ducats) for the privilege of having Jewish cemeteries guarded, but I was unable to find an English translation of the law that was passed to accommodate them. However, it was referred to in various places, I think including O’Malley, Vesalius’s biographer.

  • September 17, 2014, 3:17 pm  Reply

    Absolutely fascinating! I do have some questions though:

    First question:

    The flag-flying putto: is he protesting, or just observing? Is he confronting the authorities, or trying to get a better view? Yes, the helmeted guard seems to be looking at him, but perhaps the helmeted guard, like the guard with the shield on the right, is just literally “looking the other way” as the body is being removed.

    Why within the Fabrica would the putto be protesting? Did Vesalius protest, or express ambiguous feelings about the sources of his cadavers? Would the artist necessarily have been “protesting” in depicting such a scene?

    Second question:

    What’s with the head or headgear of the putto on the left side in line with the first column? To me, it sort of looks brain-like, and different from the more normal heads and headgear depicted.

    Bob Vietrogoski
    Special Collections
    Rutgers Biomedical and Health Sciences
    George F. Smith Library of the Health Sciences
    bob.vietrogoski@rutgers.edu

  • September 17, 2014, 10:50 am  Reply

    What a great discovery.

    You have probably seen the series that I have written on Vesalius, and a few more are coming. I had contemplated one on the initials, but I felt I couldn’t contribute much that hadn’t already been said, so Bravo! You can see my series here: http://circulatingnow.nlm.nih.gov/category/series/andreas-vesalius-at-500/

    Michael North, northm@mail.nih.gov
    Head, Rare Books and Early Manuscripts
    History of Medicine Division
    National Library of Medicine
    Bethesda, MD 20894

Leave a Comment

Dr. Jeffrey M. Levine has authored numerous articles on topics related to healthcare of the elderly. These include medical history, prevention and treatment of chronic wounds such as pressure ulcers, elder neglect and abuse, and physical restraints. He has also edited a book on legal and regulatory aspects of nursing homes.