Pressure injury staging has been central to wound care for decades. Clinicians use it to describe tissue damage, communicate findings and document care. It is also built into reimbursement, quality measurement and regulatory oversight. That raises a fair question: does a system built on Shea’s 1975 classification still match what we now know about how pressure injuries develop and heal, and about caring for frail older adults?
A System Built for a Different Purpose
The modern system traces back to Dr. J. Darrel Shea, whose 1975 paper in Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research graded pressure sores by depth of tissue involvement. Shea designed his grades to guide treatment. He also described a “closed” pressure sore: a large cavity beneath a small skin opening. In that, he recognized that the surface can understate the damage beneath it.
Wound care has since moved from treatment by stage to comprehensive assessment and wound bed preparation. Meanwhile, staging has taken on jobs Shea could scarcely have anticipated, including quality measurement, public reporting and payment.
Stages Are Not a Sequence
A persistent misconception is that pressure injuries progress in order from Stage 1 through Stage 4. The National Pressure Injury Advisory Panel (NPIAP) has long said otherwise. Even so, the numbers still suggest a timeline to many clinicians, surveyors and attorneys.
Damage often begins deep, where pressure and shear concentrate at the bone–soft tissue interface, and works outward. By the time the skin changes, substantial destruction may already have occurred. The NPIAP recognized this in 2007 by adding suspected deep tissue injury, renamed deep tissue pressure injury (DTPI) in 2016. A DTPI may open into a full-thickness wound without passing through the earlier stages, or it may resolve without opening at all.
The rules on healing make the same point. Under NPIAP guidance and the MDS 3.0, a Stage 4 wound is never “reverse staged.” As it fills in, it remains a healing Stage 4. A stage therefore records the deepest tissue loss ever observed, not necessarily the wound in front of you.
What Is Visible Is Not the Whole Wound
Staging depends on visual inspection and on recognizing anatomical structures. A small opening may conceal extensive undermining or tunneling. Wounds that look alike may differ greatly in perfusion, bioburden and healing potential. When slough or eschar covers the base, the wound is classified as “unstageable.” In effect, that category admits the system cannot classify what it cannot see.
These limits are greatest in older adults, whose tissues are often affected by impaired perfusion, diabetes, vascular disease and age-related atrophy. Newer tools, including thermography, sub-epidermal moisture measurement, ultrasound and fluorescence imaging, can detect tissue damage or bacterial burden that the eye misses. Staging was never designed to capture that information.
The Trouble With Stage 1
Stage 1 requires non-blanchable erythema of intact skin. Both erythema and blanching depend on the skin’s microcirculatory response, which is often impaired in older adults and in patients with diabetes or peripheral vascular disease. If no erythema is visible, or blanching cannot be interpreted, underlying damage has not been ruled out.
In darkly pigmented skin, erythema may be hard to see and blanching hard to assess. Clinicians must rely on temperature, tissue consistency, pain and discoloration relative to surrounding skin. The patients at greatest risk are often those in whom Stage 1 is least reliably detected.
Stage 2 or Stage 3?
Stage 2 is partial-thickness loss with exposed dermis. Stage 3 is full-thickness loss, often with visible fat. In patients with malnutrition, weight loss or atrophic skin, there may be little subcutaneous tissue to see. A shallow-looking wound may be full thickness, and depth becomes hard to judge. Similar wounds may be staged differently by different examiners. That matters little at the bedside but a great deal when the stage determines a quality metric or a payment.
Stage Does Not Dictate Treatment
Shea intended his grades to dictate treatment, with each grade pointing to a particular course of care. That is no longer how wounds are managed. Contemporary management is individualized. It depends on tissue viability, infection, vascular supply, nutrition, pain, prognosis and goals of care. Two Stage 4 wounds may call for entirely different plans. One patient may be a candidate for debridement, advanced therapies and flap closure. Another, near the end of life, may be best served by comfort, odor control and pain relief. Even necrotic tissue does not automatically call for debridement. Stable heel eschar in an ischemic limb is often best left alone.
A stage describes appearance. It does not prescribe therapy.
How Reliable Is Staging?
Accurate staging depends on recognizing anatomy and on separating pressure injury from moisture-associated skin damage, skin tears, arterial or venous ulcers and other conditions. Trained assessors can reach good agreement under study conditions. In daily practice, training, experience, lighting, photography and documentation habits all introduce variability. That variability matters most when the stage drives regulatory and financial consequences.
Staging as a Measure of Quality
The most consequential change since 1975 is the use of staging to judge quality of care and determine reimbursement. Since 2008, CMS has denied additional hospital payment for Stage 3 and 4 pressure injuries acquired during the stay. Nursing homes are measured on pressure injuries recorded in MDS Section M. Surveyors cite facilities for them, and plaintiffs’ attorneys build cases around them.
Yet pressure injuries arise from complex interactions among mechanical load, tissue tolerance, perfusion, nutrition, mobility and disease. Some frail and critically ill patients develop them despite appropriate prevention. The NPIAP has published consensus statements recognizing that some pressure injuries are unavoidable. The concepts of Skin Changes at Life’s End (SCALE) and the Kennedy terminal ulcer describe skin failure that accompanies dying. In both hospital and nursing home settings, the presence of a pressure injury is too often treated as proof of neglect.
Neither the presence nor the stage of a pressure injury establishes that it was preventable or that care was deficient. That determination requires an examination of the patient’s pre-existing comorbidities, underlying risk factors, and clinical course, as well as the interventions provided.
Where Do We Go From Here?
Standardized classification should not be abandoned. A shared language for tissue damage is valuable; the question is how much weight that language should carry. Staging is best kept as a descriptive tool rather than a timeline or a severity score. Etiology, risk, prevention efforts and goals of care should be documented in their own right, not inferred from a stage number. Imaging and other technologies should be brought into practice as they prove able to detect damage the eye cannot. Above all, quality should be judged by the care delivered in the context of the patient’s clinical condition, not by a wound classification alone.
Conclusion
Pressure injury staging has moved far beyond the treatment-oriented framework Shea proposed. It aids communication and documentation. It cannot by itself describe wound biology, determine treatment, establish preventability or measure quality of care; those judgments require the entire clinical picture. The issue is not whether to keep a standardized system. It is whether we have come to expect too much of it.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Download my article on Shea’s staging system here.
Download a PDF of Shea’s original article here.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Related posts:
Unavoidable Pressure Injuries and the “Never Event” Debate
Tube Feeding and Pressure Injuries: Is There a Benefit?
Wound Care in the Geriatrics Review Syllabus
Skin Failure: An Emerging Concept
Pressure Ulcers are an Under-Appreciated Public Health Issue
Body Casts in WWII: A Historical Perspective on Medical Device Related Pressure Ulcers
Historical Roots of the “Avoidable-Unavoidable” Pressure Ulcer Controversy